Struggling to Conceive After a Caesarean? How a Scar Defect (Isthmocele) Can Affect IVF
A new study found IVF results after a well-healed caesarean are similar to those after a vaginal birth, but a scar defect (isthmocele) lowers implantation and pregnancy rates.

Have you had a baby by caesarean section and are now finding it hard to get pregnant again? One possible reason is easy to overlook: the old caesarean scar may not have healed completely.
What is a caesarean scar defect (isthmocele)?
In some women, the caesarean wound does not heal fully. A small dip or pouch can form in the wall of the womb where the old scar is. Doctors call this a caesarean scar defect, an isthmocele or a “niche”.
Most of the time it causes no symptoms. Some women, however, notice brown spotting for several days after their period, pelvic pain or difficulty getting pregnant.
What did the study find?
A study published in BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth on 10 November 2026 looked back at the records of 2,284 women who had given birth before and were having IVF. They were divided into three groups: women who had had a vaginal birth, women who had had a caesarean with no problem at the scar, and women with a caesarean scar defect.
The results were striking:
- Women who had had a caesarean but whose scar had healed well had IVF results similar to women who had given birth vaginally.
- Women with a scar defect had lower implantation and pregnancy rates.
- The difference was most noticeable in women aged 35 or younger.
In other words, what matters is not having had a caesarean, but how the scar has healed.
Why might it affect pregnancy?
Fluid or blood can sometimes collect in the pouch at the scar. This can affect the environment inside the womb and make it harder for an embryo to implant. But not every scar defect stops a pregnancy: many women with small, symptom-free defects still conceive.
Who should be checked?
An ultrasound of the old scar can be especially useful if you:
- have had a caesarean and are now struggling to conceive again;
- have had an unsuccessful IVF cycle, particularly if good-quality embryos did not lead to a pregnancy;
- have long-lasting spotting after your periods.
A transvaginal ultrasound is usually the first step. If needed, the scar can be looked at in more detail with a saline ultrasound (sonohysterography) or a hysteroscopy.
If a defect is found, do I need surgery?
Not necessarily. Finding a scar defect does not automatically mean an operation. The decision depends on the size of the defect, how thick the remaining wall of the womb is, your symptoms and whether fluid is collecting inside the womb. For some women, monitoring is enough; for others, repair options are discussed with the doctor.
Remember: sometimes a pregnancy does not happen because of the womb the embryo needs to implant in, not because of the embryo itself. We explain what is checked after unsuccessful attempts in our article on IVF not working the first time. At Ankalife IVF Centre, your doctor will take your caesarean history into account — book a consultation.
Frequently asked questions
I’ve had a caesarean. Are my IVF chances lower?
According to this study, not if the scar has healed well: results were similar to those of women who had a vaginal birth. The difference came from having a scar defect.
How can I tell if I have a scar defect?
It often causes no symptoms, so it is usually found only on ultrasound. Prolonged spotting after periods can be a clue, but only an examination and scan by a doctor can confirm it.
Does this study give a definitive answer?
No. It is a retrospective study, so it gives an important signal rather than definitive proof. Some earlier studies have reported similar findings.
This article is for general information only and is not a diagnosis or treatment recommendation. Only a doctor can decide which tests and treatment suit you, based on an examination and your test results.
Sources
- BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth (2026) — The impact of previous caesarean delivery on IVF/ICSI outcomes: a large retrospective cohort study from Saudi Arabia
- BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth (2022) — Previous caesarean delivery and the presence of caesarean scar defects could affect pregnancy outcomes after IVF frozen-thawed embryo transfer
Still have questions? Leave your number and we will call you
Your details are used only to contact you.